Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

With only 2 ingredients, these Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich are the perfect summer time treat! Kids and adults alike will love them!

Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich with blue ice cream

This post is brought to you by Voortman Bakery. As always, the opinions are my own.

Now that Memorial Day has come and gone, it’s the best time of the year (in my opinion) – Summer! The easy breezy days of summer are upon us and it’s time to relax and enjoy this time. 

An easy dinner on the grill, playing cards on the deck and ice cream cookie sandwiches for dessert – that’s my kind of evening! 

Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich that look like Cookie Monster

No bake treats are perfect for summer! These Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches along with the Key Lime Pudding Shots, S’mores Dip Dessert Charcuterie Board, or Fruit Board with Healthy Fruit Dip make a simple dessert table for any summer celebration. 

To make these Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches, we started with our favorite cookies from Voortman Bakery. All of the Voortman Bakery products are made with no artificial colors or flavors AND no high-fructose corn syrup. 

Ingredients to make Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

Making Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches are one of the easiest desserts you will ever make, only 2 ingredients and about 5 minutes are all you need. 

Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

Ingredients

  • Cookies – we used Chocolate Chip and Oatmeal Raisin from Voortman Bakery
  • Ice Cream – your favorite flavor, we used Blue Raspberry for the Cookie Monster Ice Cream Sandwiches 
  • For Cookie Monster – eyes and a small amount of frosting to attach them to the cookie

Kitchen Essentials Needed 

  • Small cookie sheet or tray for the freezer
  • Parchment paper
  • Ice Cream Scoop 

Blue Ice Cream on top of cookie for sandwich

How to Make Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

  1. Be sure to have all the supplies out and ready, you will need to move quickly when making these. 
  2. Begin by softening the ice cream, it should be soft enough that it molds a bit when you press the cookie sandwich together. But not super soft and runny. 
  3. Add ice cream to the bottom of the cookie. Be sure to add enough to make the cookie sandwich full. 

Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich with Blue Ice Cream

And then add another cookie on top, pressing down gently. 

Place them on a tray and immediately into the freezer. 

Cookie Monster Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

If you have little ones at home, or even big kids that love Cookie Monster, adding eyes to the ice cream sandwich is fun and easy. Just a dab of frosting is all you need. 

Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich – Frequently Asked Questions

What type of cookie is best? 

You will want a firm cookie for the ice cream sandwiches. 

What ice cream is best? 

Any flavor or kind is fine. We used Blue Raspberry for the cookie monster theme. 

How long will the ice cream sandwiches last? 

After the sandwiches are frozen solid, you can wrap them or put them in a resealable bag to keep them longer. They should last up to 2 weeks in the freezer. 

How far ahead can I make these? 

If you want to serve the ice cream sandwiches at a party, I would make them at least 3 days ahead. You want them to be totally frozen. 

Can I add sprinkles or chocolate chips to the cookie sandwiches? 

Absolutely! I love that idea! We have some ideas over here

Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich with blue ice cream and eyes for Cookie Monster

Leave a Reply

Quick Recipes

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close