Welcome to Cupcake Tuesday! I’m so glad to have you! I have updated the Cupcake Heaven page, there are over 100 designs and recipes! Check it out!!
Today I have an oldie but goodie for you. I first shared these Butterfinger Cupcakes last year, but they really didn’t have a post all their own, as they shared it with other filled cupcakes. These are one of my most requested cupcakes when we head to a party or get-together. They are perfect for a birthday celebration, potluck or even a special after school treat.
As always…they are quick, easy and OH SO delicious!!
Quick and easy caramel filled Butterfinger cupcakes from HoosierHomemade.com.
Ingredients
- 1 yellow or butter flavor box cake mix plus ingredients {eggs, oil and buttermilk}
- 1 bottle Caramel Ice Cream Topping
- Buttercream Frosting or frosting of your choice
- Butterfingers candy bars {some of crushing and some mini’s for decoration, optional}
Instructions
- Mix and bake cupcakes with cake mix of your choice {I like yellow or butter flavor for this recipe}
- Cool completely.
- Using a straw, make a hole in the center of the cupcake. You can either squeeze the cake out of the straw or cut off the end.
- Carefully pour caramel topping into hole.
- Let set for a few minutes, the caramel will absorb into the cupcake.
- You can add more caramel if you want.
- Add frosting to a decorator bag that is fitted with a tip, for these I used the #1M tip.
- Pipe on frosting.
- Chop Butterfinger candy bars in the food processor or put them in a ziploc baggie and crush with a rolling pin.
- Sprinkle cupcakes with chopped Butterfingers and add a mini {bite-size} Butterfinger to the top if you like.

Did you have a chance to visit Frosting for a Cause last week? Good things are happening over there!!
A couple quick reminders…be sure to print your coupon for Kibbles ‘n Bits Dog Food {upper right sidebar} it expires soon. I’d love for you to grab a cup of coffee and join us in the Coffee Talk Community on BlogFrog.
Now it’s your turn…show off your cupcake creations! I’d appreciate a link back and be sure to check out the other cupcakes!

























Oh yum! Those look great.
Just wanted to let you know that I signed up for Frosting for the Cause and am waiting with bated breath for them to respond. Such a organization! Thanks for sharing with me.
FromTheHeartsOf recently posted..About Me
Butterfingers are one of the Hubby’s favorite candies. I may just have to use these as inspiration to make something for him as a treat.
Mama Kelly aka Jia recently posted..Carrot Apple Raisin Muffins
These Butterfinger Cupcakes look so yummy! I love the straw method in putting the caramel in. This is a cupcake idea I am going to have to try!
These look DELISH!
Courtney – Pizzazzerie.com recently posted..Giveaway The Silhouette Digital Cutting Tool!
The filling looks wonderful!
JDaniel4′s Mom recently posted..Once Upon a Sugar Tree- Bottle Cap Pendant Giveaway
I made these last night and they were a big hit. Sooooooo good. Defiant keeper recipe!!!
I made my own icing.
2 cups butter, 4 cup powdered sugar, 1 tbls vanilla, and 2-3 tbls of heaving whipping cream ( did not have any so I use regular milk lol still tasted yummy.
Then crumbled the butterfingers on top